Quick answer
Men who have had inguinal hernia repair with mesh can have robotic radical prostatectomy. The mesh, especially when placed laparoscopically, lies in the same space the operation goes through and makes surgery more demanding, particularly lymph node removal.3,7 In the studies, surgery was feasible and safe.3 In my practice, I operate on men with mesh as usual. When a hernia is found before or during prostatectomy, it can be repaired in the same operation, adding about 30 minutes.9 That decision is made case by case.
Why hernias and the prostate overlap
Inguinal hernia and prostate cancer affect the same men, at the same ages. In a series of robotic prostatectomies, the authors note that an inguinal hernia is found in 20% to 30% of men having prostate surgery.12 Many have already had a hernia repaired, some of them with mesh.
In a study of 7,206 Finnish men with prostate cancer, those who had already had hernia repair, open or laparoscopic, were more likely to have prostatectomy rather than radiotherapy than men who had never had it. Previous hernia repair did not stand in the way of choosing surgery.18
In laparoscopic repair, with the TEP and TAPP techniques, the mesh is placed in exactly this space, on the inside of the wall, over the groin. Over time, it becomes attached to the tissues and changes the planes the surgeon uses in prostatectomy.3,7 In the most common open repair, the Lichtenstein technique, the mesh sits further forward, in the inguinal canal, outside that space. That is why the authors of the Dutch survey mention it as an alternative for men who will still have prostate surgery.7
Men who already have mesh: what studies show
No study randomised patients. The data come from hospital series, reviews and a survey of surgeons:
| Study | Who was studied | What it found |
|---|---|---|
| Haifler, 2012 | 15 studies, 436 men with laparoscopic mesh, open, laparoscopic or robotic surgery | Surgery feasible and safe, more demanding; results similar to men without mesh; lymph node removal sometimes compromised3 |
| Picozzi, 2015 | 11 studies, 7,497 men, 462 with mesh | In open surgery, fewer lymph nodes removed and longer catheter time and stay; in laparoscopic surgery, no difference in blood loss or operating time; in robotic surgery, not enough data2 |
| Laungani, 2007 | 354 robotic prostatectomies, 12 with mesh | Console time of 146 minutes with mesh and 127 without hernia surgery; similar blood loss4 |
| Horovitz, 2017 | 2,927 robotic prostatectomies, 286 with mesh | Through the abdomen or outside the peritoneum, results were similar; the mesh did not rule out either approach5 |
| Bakker, 2021 | 47 urologists in the Netherlands | 49% find surgery harder after laparoscopic mesh, because of dissection behind the pubic bone, longer operating time and less complete lymph node removal7 |
| Westhofen, 2023 | 1,345 matched men, 319 with mesh | More PSA recurrence and shorter metastasis-free survival at 5 years with mesh; slower continence recovery with the same final result; similar erections and quality of life6 |
Mesh and lymph node removal
The lymph nodes removed during prostatectomy lie at the sides of the pelvis, near the blood vessels that run down to the leg. Laparoscopic mesh lies just in front of this area. That is why lymph node removal is the main concern:
- Fewer lymph nodes. In the review of 11 studies, open surgery after mesh removed fewer lymph nodes.2
- Staging. The review of 15 studies concluded that in some patients lymph node removal may not be safe and may make staging less accurate.3
- In surgeons' experience. In the Dutch survey, less complete lymph node removal was one of the most often reported difficulties.7
When lymph nodes are removed, the European guideline recommends an extended dissection.1 In my practice, I decide on lymph node removal using the Briganti nomogram, with a 7% cut-off, and when I remove them, the dissection is always extended. The page on pelvic lymph node dissection explains how it is done.
Cancer control, continence and complications
Cancer control. The review of 15 studies found no difference in cancer control.3 A German study of 6,275 men operated on at a single centre compared 319 men with mesh with 1,026 similar men without it. At 5 years, 72% of those with mesh were free of metastases, compared with 85% of those without, and PSA recurrence was also more common.6 It is a retrospective, single-centre study, and the reason for the difference is not clear. The page on PSA after prostatectomy explains follow-up.
Continence. In the German study, men with mesh took longer to regain urinary control, but final continence was the same.6 In a small Korean study, the 27 men who had had hernia repair regained continence more slowly in the first 6 months. The authors themselves advise caution with this result.8 In my practice, Kegel exercises are done before and after surgery. See the page on continence.
Complications. The review of 15 studies found complications similar to those in men without mesh.3 The review of 11 studies lists mesh-related risks that should be discussed before surgery: hernia recurrence, mesh infection or removal, mesh erosion into the bowel or bladder, bladder neck narrowing and urine leakage.2 The page on prostatectomy complications gives the figures for the operation in general.
A hernia found before or during surgery
Sometimes the hernia shows up on examination before prostatectomy. Other times, the surgeon only sees it during the operation, from inside the abdomen. In a Swiss series, 62% of the hernias repaired together with prostatectomy were diagnosed beforehand and 38% during surgery.11
With the robot already in place, the hernia can be repaired at the same time, usually with mesh. The studies show:
- 2026 review: 20 studies, 1,402 men who had both operations together and 20,405 who had prostatectomy alone. Surgery took about 30 minutes longer, with no difference in complications, blood loss or hospital stay. The hernia came back in 1.9% on average.9
- 2022 review: 13 studies. The repair added 26 minutes on average, with no extra blood loss, hospital stay or early complications. The authors point out the risks: wound or mesh infection, chronic groin pain and hernia recurrence.10
- Mesh infection: some surgeons worry about placing mesh near the freshly made join between the bladder and the urethra. In a US registry, 24 men who had both operations had 30-day complications similar to 72 men who had hernia repair alone, with no wound infection.13
- Long term: in the Swiss series, with 68 men followed for almost 9 years on average, the hernia came back in 13%, on average 43 months later. Older age increased the risk.11
The authors of the 2026 review suggest repair at the same time in selected patients, because almost all the studies are retrospective.9 In my practice, the decision to repair the hernia during the same operation is made case by case. When I repair it at the same time, I always use mesh.
I have a hernia and will still have prostate surgery
If you have a hernia and your prostate cancer is still being investigated or surgery has already been recommended, it is worth talking to your urologist before booking the hernia repair. The authors of the Dutch survey suggest postponing laparoscopic repair in these men. In their view, the best option is to repair both in the same operation, with open repair as the alternative.7
A hernia that is very painful, that no longer goes back in, or that comes with vomiting and a swollen abdomen cannot wait and needs urgent assessment. The page on inguinal hernia explains the warning signs.
A hernia after prostatectomy
Prostatectomy itself raises the risk of inguinal hernia. In a review of 54 studies with 101,687 patients, it occurred in 7.9% after robotic surgery, 7.5% after laparoscopic surgery and 13.7% after open surgery. Most (81.9%) were indirect.14 A review of 27 studies identified low body weight, a weak stream and straining to urinate before surgery, a groin canal that stayed open since birth and a hernia found incidentally during surgery as risk factors.15 Prevention techniques used during prostatectomy have shown promising results, but randomised trials are still lacking.14,15
A hernia that appears afterwards can be repaired. In a review of 16 studies with 4,655 patients who had laparoscopic or robotic repair after prostatectomy, complications during surgery were 0.7%, conversion to open surgery 0.8%, hernia recurrence 1.1% and chronic pain 1.9%.16 In a German registry of 12,465 patients, laparoscopic repair had slightly more complications during surgery, and open repair slightly more afterwards. The authors concluded that neither has a clear advantage.17
In my practice, I repair inguinal hernias by all three approaches, open, laparoscopic and robotic, with robotic surgery as the priority. The hospital stay is under 24 hours, work resumes after 14 days, and physical effort after 4 to 6 weeks. The page is inguinal hernia surgery dangerous? covers the risks of the operation.
How I approach it
I operate on men with hernia mesh as usual. At the consultation, I ask how and when your hernia was repaired, on which side and whether it was open or laparoscopic, and I review your PSA, MRI, biopsy and other tests. If there is a hernia that has not been repaired, I explain whether it makes sense to repair it in the same operation, always case by case. When I repair it at the same time, I always use mesh.
In robotic radical prostatectomy, I preserve the erection nerves whenever possible. I decide on lymph node removal using the Briganti nomogram, with a 7% cut-off, and when I remove them, the dissection is always extended. The hospital stay is 1 to 2 days, but discharge usually happens within 24 hours, still with the catheter, which stays for 7 to 10 days. Work and driving resume at 2 weeks, and sex and heavy activity at 1 month. The page on preparing for surgery explains what to do beforehand.
I have a PhD from the University of São Paulo Medical School and have performed more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. If you have obesity or previous abdominal surgery, see also the page on prostatectomy with obesity or previous surgery. If you want another assessment, a second opinion can be done entirely online, in English, with your test results sent in advance.
Send your case
If you have a hernia or have had hernia repair with mesh, have been diagnosed with prostate cancer and would like my opinion on your case before a consultation, fill in the form below. It goes to my office, and you will get a reply within 24 hours by email or WhatsApp. The form does not replace a consultation: it helps plan the next step.
Frequently asked questions
Can I have robotic prostatectomy after hernia repair with mesh?+
Yes. In a review of 15 studies with 436 men who had laparoscopic hernia repair, prostatectomy was feasible and safe, more demanding, with results similar to men without mesh.3 In my practice, I operate on men with hernia mesh as usual.
Does hernia mesh get in the way of lymph node removal?+
It can. The mesh sits in the same space where the pelvic lymph nodes are removed. In a review of 11 studies, open surgery after mesh removed fewer lymph nodes.2 In a survey of Dutch urologists, less complete lymph node removal was one of the most often reported difficulties.7
Does having hernia mesh raise the risk of the cancer coming back?+
Data are few and conflicting. A German study of 1,345 matched men found more PSA recurrence and shorter metastasis-free survival in men with mesh.6 A review of 15 studies found no difference in cancer control.3 The reason for the German finding is not yet known.
Can the hernia be repaired during the same operation as the prostatectomy?+
Yes. In a review of 20 studies, with 1,402 men who had both operations together, surgery took about 30 minutes longer, with no difference in complications, blood loss or hospital stay. The hernia came back in 1.9%.9 In my practice, the decision to repair it at the same time is made case by case and, when I do, the repair is always with mesh.
I have a hernia and will have prostate surgery. Should I have the hernia repaired first?+
Talk to your urologist first. The authors of the Dutch survey suggest postponing laparoscopic hernia repair in men being assessed for prostatectomy, preferably repairing both in the same operation, or choosing open repair.7 In my practice, this is decided case by case.
Can prostatectomy cause an inguinal hernia?+
Yes. In a review of 54 studies with 101,687 patients, inguinal hernia occurred in 7.9% after robotic prostatectomy and in 13.7% after open surgery. Most were indirect hernias.14
Can a hernia that appears after prostatectomy be repaired laparoscopically or robotically?+
Yes. In a review of 16 studies with 4,655 patients who had laparoscopic or robotic repair after prostatectomy, complications during surgery were 0.7% and hernia recurrence was 1.1%.16 In my practice, I repair inguinal hernias by all three approaches, open, laparoscopic and robotic, with robotic surgery as the priority.
Who operates on prostate cancer in men with a hernia or hernia mesh in São Paulo?+
I do. I am a urologist and robotic surgeon in São Paulo, Brazil, with a PhD from the University of São Paulo Medical School and more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. I operate on men with hernia mesh as usual, and I also repair inguinal hernias. The first consultation can be online, in English.
References
- EAU-EANM-ESTRO-ESUR-ISUP-SIOG Guidelines on Prostate Cancer: treatment. European Association of Urology; 2026. EAU
- Picozzi SC, Ricci C, Bonavina L, et al. Feasibility and outcomes regarding open and laparoscopic radical prostatectomy in patients with previous synthetic mesh inguinal hernia repair: meta-analysis and systematic review of 7,497 patients. World J Urol. 2015;33(1):59-67. PubMed
- Haifler M, Benjamin B, Ghinea R, Avital S. The impact of previous laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair on radical prostatectomy. J Endourol. 2012;26(11):1458-1462. PubMed
- Laungani RG, Kaul S, Muhletaler F, et al. Impact of previous inguinal hernia repair on transperitoneal robotic prostatectomy. Can J Urol. 2007;14(4):3635-3639. PubMed
- Horovitz D, Feng C, Messing EM, Joseph JV. Extraperitoneal vs. transperitoneal robot-assisted radical prostatectomy in patients with a history of prior inguinal hernia repair with mesh. J Robot Surg. 2017;11(4):447-454. PubMed
- Westhofen T, Bensel M, Schlenker B, et al. The impact of previous inguinal mesh hernioplasty on oncological and patient-reported outcomes following radical prostatectomy. Prostate. 2023;83(14):1313-1322. PubMed
- Bakker WJ, Roos MM, Meijer RP, Burgmans JPJ. Influence of previous laparo-endoscopic inguinal hernia repair on performing radical prostatectomy: a nationwide survey among urological surgeons. Surg Endosc. 2021;35(6):2583-2591. PubMed
- Kim SJ, Park SG, Pak S, et al. Association Between Prior Inguinal Hernia Repair and Early Continence Recovery After Robot-Assisted Radical Prostatectomy. Low Urin Tract Symptoms. 2026;18(3):e70069. PubMed
- Bruinsma J, Moynagh N, Mac Curtain BM, et al. Concurrent inguinal hernia repair during robotic radical prostatectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Hernia. 2026;30(1):64. PubMed
- Melhem M, Burki J, Algurabi O, et al. The safety and feasibility of simultaneous robotic repair of an inguinal hernia during robotic-assisted laparoscopic prostatectomy: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Scand J Urol. 2022;56(3):197-205. PubMed
- Peixoto N, Grobet-Jeandin E, Schoofs F, et al. Long term efficacy of prosthetic inguinal herniorrhaphy concomitant with robot-assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy. World J Urol. 2023;41(11):3169-3174. PubMed
- Finley DS, Rodriguez E Jr, Ahlering TE. Combined inguinal hernia repair with prosthetic mesh during transperitoneal robot assisted laparoscopic radical prostatectomy: a 4-year experience. J Urol. 2007;178(4 Pt 1):1296-1299. PubMed
- de Figueiredo SMP, Tastaldi L, Mao RD, et al. Short-term outcomes of robotic inguinal hernia repair during robotic prostatectomy: an analysis of the Abdominal Core Health Quality Collaborative. Am J Surg. 2023;225(2):383-387. PubMed
- Alder R, Zetner D, Rosenberg J. Incidence of Inguinal Hernia after Radical Prostatectomy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Urol. 2020;203(2):265-274. PubMed
- Fernando H, Garcia C, Hossack T, et al. Incidence, Predictive Factors and Preventive Measures for Inguinal Hernia following Robotic and Laparoscopic Radical Prostatectomy: A Systematic Review. J Urol. 2019;201(6):1072-1079. PubMed
- Aiolfi A, Bona D, Calì M, et al. Is previous radical prostatectomy a contraindication to minimally invasive inguinal hernia repair? A contemporary meta-analysis. Hernia. 2024;28(5):1525-1536. PubMed
- Trawa M, Albrecht HC, Köckerling F, et al. Outcome of inguinal hernia repair after previous radical prostatectomy: a registry-based analysis with 12,465 patients. Hernia. 2022;26(4):1143-1152. PubMed
- Ahtinen M, Vironen J, Murtola TJ. Previous inguinal hernia surgery does not limit the likelihood of choosing prostatectomy as primary prostate cancer therapy. Sci Rep. 2024;14(1):9943. PubMed
Would you like to talk about your case?
In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.
Book a consultation5.0186 Google reviews
