Quick answer
A positive margin means that, on the prostatectomy pathology report, the tumor touches the inked edge of the specimen at some point.1 In a study of 13,090 robotic prostatectomies, it was found in 22% of patients.2 On its own, it does not mean the cancer will come back. In my practice, when the margin is positive and the PSA stays undetectable, I monitor the PSA, as the European guideline advises.4
What a positive margin is
Under the International Society of Urological Pathology (ISUP) consensus, tumor close to the edge but not touching the ink is a negative margin. When the margin is positive, the report should say where it is (apex, middle or base of the prostate, bladder neck, back or sides) and how many millimeters it measures.1
The page on the prostatectomy pathology report explains the other items on the report.
How often it happens
In a 2024 study of 13,090 patients operated on by 74 surgeons at 10 centers in Europe and North America, the margin was positive in 22% of robotic prostatectomies. The chance fell as the surgeon gained experience: 26% after 10 prior operations, 18% after 500 and 14% after 2,000.2 The page on robotic radical prostatectomy covers surgeon experience in more detail.
Other factors matter, according to the European guideline:4
- Planning before surgery: a review of 8 studies found fewer positive margins when surgery was planned with nomograms or MRI.
- Weight and previous surgery: obesity and a previous transurethral resection of the prostate (TURP) were linked to more positive margins.
- Nerve sparing: across 18 studies, positive margins on the spared side were more common, with no difference in PSA recurrence. The studies mostly included low-risk patients and had short follow-up.
When the margin matters more
A review of 31 studies with 50,028 patients showed that not every positive margin carries the same weight. These were linked to a higher chance of a rising PSA:3
- a margin of 3 mm or more
- margins at several sites
- Gleason 4 or 5 at the margin
- a tumor extending beyond the prostate (pT3)
The European guideline describes a risk of progression of up to 50% at 5 years with ISUP grade above 2 and a pT3a tumor, and particularly with seminal vesicle invasion (pT3b) or a positive margin.4
Radiotherapy right away or only if the PSA rises
Two studies published in 2020 compared these approaches:
- RADICALS-RT: 1,396 men with at least one risk factor, including a positive margin. At 5 years, 85% of those given radiotherapy right away were free of PSA recurrence, compared with 88% of those who waited. Immediate radiotherapy caused more urine leakage at 1 year and more urethral narrowing. In the group that waited, only 33% needed radiotherapy within 8 years.5
- ARTISTIC: an analysis of three randomized trials with 2,153 men found no advantage for immediate radiotherapy: 89% versus 88% free of progression at 5 years.6
Based on these studies, the European guideline states that the vast majority of patients with an undetectable PSA after surgery do not need immediate radiotherapy. It is still recommended in selected cases, with ISUP grade 4 or 5 and a pT3 tumor, with or without a positive margin.4
How I approach it
When the margin is positive and the PSA stays undetectable, I monitor the PSA closely, as the European guideline advises.4 If it starts to rise, we discuss salvage radiotherapy. The page on PSA after prostatectomy explains the values and timelines.
On the report, I go over the length, the number and the Gleason grade of the margin with you, because these are what change the risk.3 For my PhD at the University of São Paulo Medical School, I studied slides of prostates removed by radical prostatectomy, and that reading is part of the consultation.
If you were operated on by another surgeon and want a second opinion, the consultation can be online, in English, with the report and your PSA values sent in advance.
Frequently asked questions
Does a positive margin mean the cancer has come back?+
No. It means the tumor touches the inked edge of the specimen at some point.1 What shows whether the cancer has come back is the PSA. A positive margin raises the risk of a rising PSA, especially when it measures 3 mm or more, appears at several sites or has Gleason 4 or 5.3
Do I need radiotherapy if the margin is positive?+
Usually not right after surgery. In three randomized trials with 2,153 men, immediate radiotherapy was not better than waiting and giving salvage radiotherapy if the PSA rose.6 The European guideline reserves immediate radiotherapy for selected cases, with ISUP grade 4 or 5 and a pT3 tumor.4
Is a positive margin the surgeon's fault?+
Not necessarily. It depends a great deal on the tumor, especially when it already extends beyond the prostate, and on nerve sparing. Even with surgeons who had performed 2,000 robotic prostatectomies, the estimated chance was 14% in a study of 13,090 patients. With 10 operations of experience, it was 26%.2
What does a focal margin or a margin under 3 mm mean?+
It is a small positive margin at a single site. In a review of 31 studies, margins of 3 mm or more were linked to a higher chance of a rising PSA than smaller ones.3 That is why the report should give the length in millimeters and the location.1
Who can follow up a positive margin after prostatectomy in São Paulo?+
I do, also for patients operated on by another surgeon, in person or online, in English. I am a urologist and robotic surgeon in São Paulo, Brazil, CRM-SP 157.598 and RQE 70.275. I hold a PhD from the University of São Paulo Medical School, with research on radical prostatectomy slides, and have performed more than 500 robotic surgeries.
References
- Tan PH, Cheng L, Srigley JR, et al. International Society of Urological Pathology (ISUP) Consensus Conference on Handling and Staging of Radical Prostatectomy Specimens. Working group 5: surgical margins. Mod Pathol. 2011;24(1):48-57. PubMed
- Bravi CA, Dell'Oglio P, Piazza P, et al. Positive Surgical Margins After Anterior Robot-assisted Radical Prostatectomy: Assessing the Learning Curve in a Multi-institutional Collaboration. Eur Urol Oncol. 2024;7(4):821-828. PubMed
- Guo H, Zhang L, Shao Y, et al. The impact of positive surgical margin parameters and pathological stage on biochemical recurrence after radical prostatectomy: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2024;19(7):e0301653. PubMed
- EAU-EANM-ESTRO-ESUR-ISUP-SIOG Guidelines on Prostate Cancer: treatment. European Association of Urology; 2026. EAU
- Parker CC, Clarke NW, Cook AD, et al. Timing of radiotherapy after radical prostatectomy (RADICALS-RT): a randomised, controlled phase 3 trial. Lancet. 2020;396(10260):1413-1421. PubMed
- Vale CL, Fisher D, Kneebone A, et al. Adjuvant or early salvage radiotherapy for the treatment of localised and locally advanced prostate cancer: a prospectively planned systematic review and meta-analysis of aggregate data. Lancet. 2020;396(10260):1422-1431. PubMed
Would you like to talk about your case?
In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.
Book a consultation
