Quick answer
A transvesical prostatectomy, also called a suprapubic prostatectomy or Freyer's operation, treats an enlarged prostate (benign prostatic hyperplasia). The surgeon opens the bladder and, from inside it, removes the benign tissue that squeezes the urethra. The prostate capsule stays in place.1,2 It can be open or robotic and is used for large prostates, usually above 80 g.1 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case. The other route is through the capsule, Millin's technique, which is the one I usually use in robotic simple prostatectomy. HoLEP, done through the urethra, is also part of the conversation.
What a prostatectomy is
Prostatectomy is the name for any operation that removes the prostate or part of it, which is why the word causes confusion. There are two very different operations:
- Radical prostatectomy treats prostate cancer. It removes the whole prostate, with the seminal vesicles, and the bladder is joined back to the urethra.
- Simple prostatectomy treats an enlarged prostate, which is benign. It removes only the tissue inside the prostate that squeezes the urethra and leaves the capsule in place.1
A transvesical prostatectomy is a form of simple prostatectomy. It is not done for cancer.
What a transvesical prostatectomy is
The name describes the route: "vesical" refers to the bladder. In a transvesical prostatectomy, the surgeon opens the bladder and reaches, from inside it, the prostate tissue that blocks the urine. With a finger, the surgeon separates this tissue from the capsule and removes it.1 Peter Freyer published the first cases operated on this way in London, in 1901, which is why it is also called Freyer's operation.2 You may also hear suprapubic prostatectomy, because the incision is above the pubic bone, or transvesical adenomectomy.
It is still widely used. In Germany, from 2013 to 2023, 44,194 open simple prostatectomies were performed, and 73% of them went through the bladder.4
How open surgery is done
- IncisionOpen surgery starts with an incision in the lower abdomen, above the pubic bone.
- Opening the bladderThe surgeon moves aside the fat in front of the bladder and opens its front wall.
- Removing the tissueFrom inside the bladder, the surgeon finds the bladder neck, where the urethra begins, and uses a finger to separate the enlarged tissue from the prostate capsule.1
- ClosingBleeding is controlled, the bladder is closed, and a catheter stays in through the urethra.
In a series of 902 open operations in Germany, the operation lasted about 81 minutes on average, and the tissue removed weighed about 85 g.11 In a study from the United States, men who had open surgery needed continuous bladder irrigation with saline, and the catheter stayed for a median of 10 days.10
Through the bladder or through the capsule: Freyer or Millin
In 1945, Terence Millin described another route that does not open the bladder. The surgeon goes through the space between the pubic bone and the bladder, the Retzius space, and opens the prostate capsule from the front.1,3 This is retropubic prostatectomy. The tissue removed is the same with both routes.
| Item | Through the bladder (Freyer) | Through the capsule (Millin) |
|---|---|---|
| How the tissue is reached | From inside the bladder, at the bladder neck | Through the front of the capsule, via the Retzius space1 |
| Bladder | Opened and then closed | Not opened |
| Can be done with the robot | Yes | Yes1 |
| Bladder problems at the same time | Authors consider it better suited when there are bladder problems5 | In my practice, this is the routine route; when there is a bladder stone, I use the route through the bladder, with the robot |
Few studies have compared the two routes. In the German national database, among open operations, those done through the capsule had a shorter hospital stay and fewer ICU admissions than those done through the bladder.4 In a German hospital with 100 robotic operations, the route through the capsule had a shorter console time (71 and 91 minutes), a shorter catheter time (4.3 and 6.7 days) and fewer major complications (3.3% and 12.5%). The men operated on through the bladder already had more symptoms before surgery, and it is a small, single-center study. The authors concluded that the route through the capsule may allow a quicker recovery, and that the route through the bladder is better suited to cases with bladder problems.5 In a study of 45 men operated on with the robot in Rome, symptoms, continence, complications and hospital stay were similar between the routes.6
Open or robotic
With the robot or by laparoscopy, simple prostatectomy follows the same logic as open surgery, through the bladder or through the capsule, through small cuts in the abdomen.1 Compared with open surgery, the small-cut approach had a shorter hospital stay, less bleeding and fewer transfusions, with a longer operation and similar urinary results.1 The numbers from this comparison are in open or robotic simple prostatectomy.
Robotic surgery through the bladder has also been studied. In a series of 292 men operated on by a single surgeon in the United States, symptom scores fell from 17.9 to 5.7 points, none needed another operation to urinate and none developed narrowing of the bladder neck. About five and a half years later, 98.9% of those who answered the survey had no stress urinary leakage.8 In a US center that performed 117 of these operations with a single-port robot, which goes straight into the bladder through a 3 cm incision, 95.8% of the men analyzed went home within 24 hours, and none needed a transfusion.9
Who it is for
A transvesical prostatectomy is an option when the prostate is large and medications do not bring enough relief, or when the enlarged prostate has already caused complications, such as urinary retention that comes back.1 According to the European guideline, open surgery is used for prostates above 80 to 100 g, and the robotic or laparoscopic approach is feasible above 80 g.1 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case.
The guideline recommends open surgery for prostates above 80 g when endoscopic enucleation, such as HoLEP, is not available.1 A bladder stone or diverticulum also weighs on the choice of technique, because robotic surgery allows these problems to be treated at the same time.7
Recovery and risks
The numbers for open surgery come from large series. In the German series of 902 men, complications occurred in 17.3%. Transfusion was needed in 7.5%, urinary tract infection occurred in 5.1%, and 3.7% had to go back to the operating room for bleeding. In 3.1%, examination of the tissue found cancer.11 In a survey of 1,804 open operations done in southern Italy in 1997 and 1998, the median hospital stay was 7 days, and 3.6% had another operation within 2 years, mostly for narrowing of the bladder neck.12
According to the European guideline, the transfusion rate in open surgery is around 7% to 14%, and late complications, such as persistent urine leakage and narrowing of the bladder neck or urethra, occur in about 6%. Mortality has fallen over recent decades and is below 0.25%. In a national database from Austria, 3% needed another operation through the urethra within 1 year, and 8.8% within 8 years.1 In a study from a US center, robotic surgery through the bladder, with the single-port robot, allowed same-day discharge and a 7-day catheter, compared with a 2-day hospital stay and a 10-day catheter with open surgery.10
Retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common after operations for an enlarged prostate, and erections, after most of them, do not seem to change.14 In my practice, retrograde ejaculation happens in almost every patient after robotic simple prostatectomy. What changes with each technique is in ejaculation and erections. The complications, one by one, are in simple prostatectomy complications, and day-to-day life after the operation is in simple prostatectomy recovery.
The alternatives
A transvesical prostatectomy is one of several options for a large prostate, and all of them are part of the conversation:
- HoLEP removes the same tissue through the urethra, with a laser, without an abdominal incision. In the reviews cited by the European guideline, open surgery through the bladder and HoLEP had similar urinary results, and open surgery had a longer catheter time, a longer hospital stay and more transfusions.1 In a randomized study of 120 men with prostates above 100 g, symptoms and urinary stream were the same with both 5 years later, and a second operation was needed in 5% after HoLEP and 6.7% after open surgery.13
- Robotic simple prostatectomy removes the same tissue through small cuts, through the bladder or through the capsule. I compare the two operations in simple prostatectomy or HoLEP.
- Greenlight is also used for large prostates.
What each technique can handle at each size is in which technique for each prostate size.
How I approach it
I have performed robotic simple prostatectomy since 2020, and I have performed more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. The approach through the bladder is one of the options, and it can also be done with the robot. I usually use the modified Millin technique: I reach the prostate through the Retzius space, open the capsule, remove the tissue, suture the bladder neck to the urethra and close the capsule. When there is also a bladder stone, I use the approach through the bladder with the robot, to treat the stone and the prostate at the same time.
In my practice, anesthesia is general, the hospital stay is under 24 hours, and the catheter stays for 5 to 7 days. Blood in the urine is common in the first days. Return to work and to driving is at 2 weeks, and sex and heavy activity after 1 month. I recommend pelvic floor (Kegel) exercises before and after surgery.
If there is a bladder stone, I treat it during the same operation. A bladder diverticulum is not repaired routinely, and this is assessed case by case. For simple prostatectomy, the anticoagulant is always stopped. If you cannot stop it, I consider another type of surgery: in my practice, HoLEP is possible even in people who take anticoagulants.
Before recommending surgery, I look at the size of the prostate, whether there is a stone or diverticulum in the bladder, your other illnesses, your medications and what you want to preserve. Open surgery, robotic surgery and the techniques through the urethra are all options, and we make the decision together.
When to see a urologist
- If you were advised to have a transvesical or suprapubic prostatectomy and want to understand the options
- If your prostate is large and medications do not bring enough relief
- If you have had urinary retention or use a catheter
- If you have a bladder stone along with an enlarged prostate
Frequently asked questions
What is a prostatectomy?+
It is an operation that removes the prostate or part of it. A radical prostatectomy removes the whole prostate and is done for cancer. A simple prostatectomy removes only the benign tissue inside the prostate that squeezes the urethra in an enlarged prostate (benign prostatic hyperplasia), and the capsule stays in place.1
What is a transvesical prostatectomy?+
It is a simple prostatectomy in which the surgeon opens the bladder and, from inside it, removes the benign prostate tissue that squeezes the urethra. The tissue is separated from the capsule with a finger. This is the route Freyer described in 1901.1,2
Is a suprapubic prostatectomy the same as a transvesical prostatectomy?+
In practice, yes. Suprapubic prostatectomy, Freyer's operation and transvesical adenomectomy are names for the same operation, done through the bladder with an incision above the pubic bone.2
What is the difference between a transvesical and a retropubic prostatectomy?+
In the transvesical approach (Freyer), the surgeon reaches the tissue from inside the bladder. In the retropubic approach (Millin), the surgeon goes through the space between the pubic bone and the bladder and opens the prostate capsule from the front, without opening the bladder.1,3
Can a transvesical prostatectomy be done with the robot?+
Yes. With the robot or by laparoscopy, the operation follows the route through the bladder or through the capsule.1 In a series of 292 men operated on with the robot through the bladder, symptom scores fell from 17.9 to 5.7 points, and none needed another operation to urinate.8
What prostate size is a transvesical prostatectomy for?+
According to the European guideline, open surgery is used for prostates above 80 to 100 g, and the robotic or laparoscopic approach is feasible above 80 g.1 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case.
How long are the hospital stay and the catheter?+
It depends on the type of operation. In a survey of 1,804 open operations, the median hospital stay was 7 days.12 In a study of open surgery, the catheter stayed for a median of 10 days.10 In my practice, robotic simple prostatectomy has a hospital stay under 24 hours, and the catheter stays for 5 to 7 days.
What are the risks of an open transvesical prostatectomy?+
In a series of 902 open operations in Germany, complications occurred in 17.3%. Transfusion was needed in 7.5%, urinary tract infection occurred in 5.1%, and 3.7% had to go back to the operating room for bleeding.11 Later on, persistent urine leakage and narrowing of the bladder neck or urethra can occur, in about 6%.1
Does ejaculation change after a transvesical prostatectomy?+
Retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common after operations for an enlarged prostate.14 In my practice, it happens in almost every patient after robotic simple prostatectomy.
Does a transvesical prostatectomy remove the whole prostate?+
No. It removes the benign tissue inside the prostate, and the capsule stays.1 The operation that removes the whole prostate is radical prostatectomy, done for cancer.
What is the alternative to a transvesical prostatectomy?+
For large prostates, HoLEP, done through the urethra, had results similar to those of open surgery, with a shorter catheter time, a shorter hospital stay and fewer transfusions.1 Robotic simple prostatectomy, through the bladder or through the capsule, is another option. The choice is made case by case.
Who can I talk to about a transvesical prostatectomy in São Paulo?+
I am Dr. Petronio Melo, a urologist and robotic surgeon, CRM-SP 157.598 and RQE 70.275. I have performed robotic simple prostatectomy since 2020, and I have performed more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. I have experience with all current techniques for enlarged prostate, with more than 500 Greenlight procedures and extensive experience with HoLEP, and I was one of the pioneers of Rezum in Brazil, with more than 100 cases between my own patients and proctoring. I go over with you the operation through the bladder, through the capsule, open or robotic, and the techniques through the urethra. My office is in Vila Mariana, and the first consultation can be in person or online, in English.
References
- EAU Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male LUTS. European Association of Urology; 2026. Disease management chapter. EAU
- Freyer PJ. A clinical lecture on total extirpation of the prostate for radical cure of enlargement of that organ: with four successful cases. Br Med J. 1901;2(2116):125-9. PubMed
- Millin T. Retropubic prostatectomy: a new extravesical technique report on 20 cases. 1945. J Urol. 2002;167(2 Pt 2):976-9. PubMed
- Pyrgidis N, Weinhold P, Schulz GB, et al. Peri-operative outcomes of open, laparoscopic and robotic simple prostatectomy. BJU Int. 2025;136(6):1107-1113. PubMed
- Farzat M, Wagenlehner FM. Transvesical vs Transcapsular Robot-Assisted Multiport Simple Prostatectomy: A Comparative Analysis of Perioperative Outcomes. J Endourol. 2025;39(12):1316-1323. PubMed
- Bove AM, Anceschi U, Ferriero M, et al. Perioperative and 1-year patient-reported outcomes of Freyer versus Millin versus Madigan robot-assisted simple prostatectomy. World J Urol. 2021;39(6):2005-2010. PubMed
- Cho JM, Moon KT, Yoo TK. Robotic simple prostatectomy: why and how? Int Neurourol J. 2020;24(1):12-20. PubMed
- Shumaker L, Leopold Z, Perilstein M, et al. Robot-assisted transvesical simple prostatectomy with circumferential mucosal anastomosis: long-term urinary and sexual function outcomes in a 292 patient cohort. J Robot Surg. 2025;19(1):693. PubMed
- Ramos R, Ferguson E, Abou Zeinab M, et al. Single-port Transvesical Robot-Assisted Simple Prostatectomy: Surgical Technique and Clinical Outcomes. Eur Urol. 2024;85(5):445-456. PubMed
- Abou Zeinab M, Kaviani A, Ferguson E, et al. Single-port transvesical versus open simple prostatectomy: a perioperative comparative study. Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis. 2023;26(3):538-542. PubMed
- Gratzke C, Schlenker B, Seitz M, et al. Complications and early postoperative outcome after open prostatectomy in patients with benign prostatic enlargement: results of a prospective multicenter study. J Urol. 2007;177(4):1419-22. PubMed
- Serretta V, Morgia G, Fondacaro L, et al. Open prostatectomy for benign prostatic enlargement in southern Europe in the late 1990s: a contemporary series of 1800 interventions. Urology. 2002;60(4):623-7. PubMed
- Kuntz RM, Lehrich K, Ahyai SA. Holmium laser enucleation of the prostate versus open prostatectomy for prostates greater than 100 grams: 5-year follow-up results of a randomised clinical trial. Eur Urol. 2008;53(1):160-6. PubMed
- Manfredi C, García-Gómez B, Arcaniolo D, et al. Impact of Surgery for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia on Sexual Function: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Erectile Function and Ejaculatory Function. Eur Urol Focus. 2022;8(6):1711-1732. PubMed
Would you like to talk about your case?
In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.
Book a consultation
