Quick answer
Robotic simple prostatectomy and HoLEP remove the same tissue: the enlarged part inside the prostate. In both, the capsule stays. The robotic operation reaches that tissue from the outside, through small cuts in the abdomen, and HoLEP from the inside, through the urethra, with the holmium laser. In the randomized trial, in prostates of 120 g or more, the result for urination was similar at about 2 years.2 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case. In the reviews, HoLEP had a catheter time about 4 days shorter and fewer transfusions.3,4 In my practice, both have a hospital stay under 24 hours. The catheter stays for 5 to 7 days after the robotic operation and comes out before discharge after HoLEP.
What the two have in common
Both operations take out the tissue that squeezes the urinary channel and leave the prostate capsule in place. The surgeon finds the plane between that tissue and the capsule and frees the tissue whole. In both, the tissue goes to the laboratory for examination.
The European guideline recommends HoLEP as an alternative to TURP and open surgery, without naming a weight limit, and describes the robotic or laparoscopic approach as feasible in prostates over 80 g, while randomized trials are still awaited.1 In practice, size has to be assessed case by case.
What changes: from the outside or from the inside
In robotic simple prostatectomy, the robot's instruments enter through small cuts in the abdomen. I use the modified Millin technique: I reach the prostate through the Retzius space, between the pubic bone and the bladder, open the capsule and remove the tissue. Then I suture the bladder neck to the urethra and close the capsule. The tissue comes out whole through one of the cuts.
In HoLEP, there is no cut in the skin. The instrument goes in through the urethra, and the holmium laser frees the tissue from the capsule. I use the en bloc technique, in which the tissue comes free in a single piece. It goes into the bladder, where it is broken up and removed.
Because it is done through the abdomen, the robotic operation is more invasive, and the anesthetic risk is comparatively higher.7
What the studies show
| Item | Robotic simple | HoLEP |
|---|---|---|
| Route | Small cuts in the abdomen | Through the urethra, no cut |
| Symptoms, stream and quality of life | Similar | Similar |
| Catheter | About 4 days longer | Shorter |
| Hospital stay | Same or longer | Same or shorter |
| Bleeding and transfusion | More transfusions | Fewer transfusions |
| Operating time | Same or longer | Same or shorter |
| Serious complications | Same or more frequent | Same or less frequent |
| Urine leakage after surgery | Same or less frequent | Same or more frequent |
| Ejaculation | Retrograde very common | Retrograde very common |
| Second operation | Rare | Rare |
| Bladder stone or diverticulum | Stone and diverticulum can be treated at the same time | Stone treated at the same time, through the urethra |
The randomized trial that compared the two included 110 men with prostates of 120 g or more, randomly assigned to laparoscopic surgery, robotic surgery or HoLEP and followed for 26 months on average. Urinary results and complications were not different. The catheter stayed longer only after laparoscopic surgery. Surgery from the outside, laparoscopic or robotic, had a longer hospital stay and fewer new irritative symptoms, such as urinary urgency.2
The reviews pool mostly non-randomized studies. In one from 2026, with 13 studies and 1,993 men, HoLEP had an operation 32 minutes shorter, catheter removal 3.8 days earlier, odds of transfusion about one third of those with the robotic operation and fewer serious complications. Hospital stay, stream, quality of life and urine leakage were not different, and the symptom score was less than 1 point better with the robotic operation.3 In another review, HoLEP shortened the operation by 49 minutes, the hospital stay by 1.5 days and the catheter time by 3.8 days, with a 75% lower risk of transfusion.4
A review of 15 studies, with 2,231 men, found two points in favor of the robotic operation: urine leakage was less frequent, and the symptom score was slightly better after 1 year. The catheter time and the operation were shorter with the laser, and the hospital stay was not different between the robotic operation and HoLEP.5
In prostates of 200 g or more, a Belgian center compared 31 men operated on robotically and 22 with HoLEP. The improvement in stream, the complications and the catheter time (median of 3 and 2 days) were similar.6 A German review on prostates over 200 g describes enucleation through the urethra as possible at any size and with the least morbidity, but difficult even for experienced surgeons in extreme prostates. The robotic operation appears as an alternative, with greater morbidity and anesthetic risk.7 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case.
Studies comparing the two over the long term are still lacking.3 In a series of 949 men operated on with HoLEP at a Canadian center and followed for 5 years on average, 0.7% needed another operation for leftover tissue.12 In a series of 292 men who had the robotic operation through the bladder, none needed another operation for urination, with an average follow-up of almost 2 years.13
Bladder stone or diverticulum
A bladder stone and a diverticulum, a pouch that forms in the bladder wall, can appear when the prostate obstructs the outflow of urine. The European guideline lists both among the situations in which surgery is usually needed.1
In the robotic operation, the bladder is within reach of the instruments, and a large stone or a diverticulum can be treated at the same time.7,8 In HoLEP, the stone is broken up and removed through the urethra during the same operation.9 In a review of 7 studies, treating the prostate together with the stone lowered the chance of the stone coming back and improved symptoms, with more minor complications and no difference in serious ones.10
In my practice, when there is a bladder stone, I treat the stone at the same time, in both operations. A diverticulum is not repaired routinely: this is assessed case by case.
If you take blood thinners
In my practice, before robotic simple prostatectomy, I always stop the anticoagulant. If you cannot stop the medication, I consider another type of operation. HoLEP is possible even in men who take anticoagulants: I stop the medication when possible and, when it is not, I operate with it. I perform Greenlight without stopping the anticoagulant.
The European guideline describes laser enucleation performed safely in men who use anticoagulant or antiplatelet medications, although there are still no randomized trials.1 The decision to stop the medication or not is made together with the doctor who prescribed it, never on your own. More details in HoLEP for men on blood thinners or with a catheter.
Ejaculation and erection
Retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common after surgery for an enlarged prostate, and erections, after most of these operations, do not seem to change.11 In the review of 13 studies, the erection score was not different between the robotic operation and HoLEP.3 In my practice, retrograde ejaculation happens in almost every patient after robotic simple prostatectomy, and HoLEP almost never preserves ejaculation. See what changes with each technique in ejaculation and erections.
Both in my practice
| Item | Robotic simple | HoLEP |
|---|---|---|
| Technique | Modified Millin, through the Retzius space | En bloc |
| I have performed it since | 2020 | 2022 |
| Anesthesia | General | General |
| Hospital stay | Under 24 hours | Usually less than 24 hours |
| Catheter | 5 to 7 days | Comes out before discharge |
| Work and driving | 2 weeks | 2 weeks |
| Sex and heavy activity | 1 month | 1 month |
| Ejaculation | Retrograde in almost everyone | Almost never preserved |
| Anticoagulant | I always stop it | I stop it when possible; if not, I operate with it |
| Bladder stone | Treated at the same time | Treated at the same time |
| Patients from another city in Brazil | Go home after 2 days, still with the catheter, and have it removed in your home city, or stay until it is removed | Stay at least 2 days in São Paulo |
After the robotic operation, patients who live in another city choose whether to go home with the catheter or stay until it is removed, and the catheter is removed at my office. For both operations, the first consultation and the follow-up visits after you go home can be online.
How I approach it
I perform both operations: robotic simple prostatectomy since 2020 and HoLEP since 2022, using the en bloc technique. Before recommending one of them, I go over with you:
- the size and shape of the prostate
- whether there is a stone or diverticulum in the bladder
- whether you take an anticoagulant and whether you can stop it
- your other conditions and the anesthetic risk
- how much it matters to you to spend less time with a catheter
Men who have already had prostate surgery through the urethra and whose obstruction came back can also have either of the two: the European guideline cites studies of both in this situation.1 The decision is made together with you.
When to see a urologist
- If you have a large prostate and want to compare robotic surgery with HoLEP
- If you have a bladder stone or diverticulum
- If you take an anticoagulant and need prostate surgery
- If medications no longer help or you have already needed a catheter
Send your case
If you would like to know, before a consultation, which technique makes sense for your case, fill in the form below. If you know it, tell me the prostate weight on ultrasound or MRI and the medications you take. It goes to my office, and you will get a reply within 24 hours by email or WhatsApp. The form does not replace a consultation: it helps plan the next step.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between robotic simple prostatectomy and HoLEP?+
Both remove the enlarged tissue from inside the prostate, and the capsule stays. In the robotic operation, I reach that tissue from the outside, through small cuts in the abdomen. In HoLEP, I reach it from the inside, through the urethra, with the holmium laser and no cut in the skin.1
Robotic simple prostatectomy or HoLEP: which is better?+
For urination, the result was similar in the randomized trial in prostates of 120 g or more.2 In the reviews, HoLEP had a catheter time about 4 days shorter and fewer transfusions.3,4 The robotic operation makes it possible to treat a bladder diverticulum at the same time.8 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case, and the choice is made together with you.
Which one means less time with a catheter?+
HoLEP. In the reviews, the catheter came out about 3.8 days earlier.3,4 In my practice, after HoLEP the catheter comes out before discharge, and after the robotic operation it stays for 5 to 7 days.
Which one bleeds less?+
HoLEP. In a review of 13 studies, the odds of transfusion were about one third of those with the robotic operation, and in another the risk was 75% lower.3,4 In the randomized trial, complications were not different.2
I have a bladder stone or diverticulum. Which should I choose?+
In the robotic operation, a large stone or a diverticulum can be treated at the same time.7,8 In HoLEP, the stone is removed through the urethra during the same operation.9 In my practice, the stone is treated at the same time in both operations. A diverticulum is not repaired routinely, and this is assessed case by case.
If I take blood thinners, which of the two can I have?+
In my practice, before robotic simple prostatectomy, I always stop the anticoagulant. If you cannot stop the medication, I consider another operation. HoLEP is possible even with the anticoagulant, and the European guideline describes laser enucleation performed safely in men who use these medications.1
Does ejaculation change after either operation?+
Often. Retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common after surgery for an enlarged prostate.11 In my practice, it happens in almost every patient after robotic simple prostatectomy, and HoLEP almost never preserves ejaculation.
Who performs robotic simple prostatectomy in São Paulo?+
I perform robotic simple prostatectomy in São Paulo. I am Dr. Petronio Melo, a urologist and robotic surgeon, a reference in the treatment of the enlarged prostate (BPH), CRM-SP 157.598 and RQE 70.275. I have performed robotic simple prostatectomy since 2020 and HoLEP since 2022, using the en bloc technique, and I have performed more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. In my practice, both operations have a hospital stay under 24 hours. My office is in Vila Mariana, and the first consultation can be in person or online, in English.
References
- EAU Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male LUTS. European Association of Urology; 2026. Disease management chapter. EAU
- Fuschi A, Al Salhi Y, Velotti G, et al. Holmium laser enucleation of prostate versus minimally invasive simple prostatectomy for large volume (≥120 mL) prostate glands: a prospective multicenter randomized study. Minerva Urol Nephrol. 2021;73(5):638-648. PubMed
- Garcia GL, Pompeu BF, Barone GL, et al. Holmium laser enucleation of the prostate versus robot-assisted simple prostatectomy for benign prostatic obstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis with trial sequential analysis. J Laparoendosc Adv Surg Tech A. 2026;36(12):881-95. PubMed
- Benzouak T, Addar A, Prudencio-Brunello MA, et al. Comparative analysis of holmium laser enucleation of the prostate and robotic-assisted simple prostatectomy in benign prostatic hyperplasia management: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Urol. 2025;213(2):150-61. PubMed
- Hao X, Wang S, Deng F, et al. Robot-assisted simple prostatectomy vs. laser enucleation of the prostate for large-volume benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH, ≥80 mL): a systematic review and meta-analysis. Front Med (Lausanne). 2026;13:1804731. PubMed
- Van der Jeugt J, Umari P, Mottaran A, et al. Holmium laser enucleation of the prostate vs robot-assisted simple prostatectomy for lower urinary tract symptoms in patients with extremely large prostates ≥200 cc: a comparative analysis. J Endourol. 2023;37(8):895-902. PubMed
- Hartung FO, Gruene B, Becker B, et al. Prostate surgery for benign prostatic syndrome >200 ml: endoscopic, robotic, or open approach. Aktuelle Urol. 2024;55(3):213-8. PubMed
- Cho JM, Moon KT, Yoo TK. Robotic simple prostatectomy: why and how? Int Neurourol J. 2020;24(1):12-20. PubMed
- Savin Z, Mendelson T, Rahmani LD, et al. Personalizing BPH management: bladder stone removal alone vs. with concomitant laser enucleation. A multicenter perspective with patient reported outcomes and decisional regret analysis. Prostate. 2026;86(7):831-8. PubMed
- Cormio A, Giulioni C, Falsetti F, et al. Concomitant benign prostatic enlargement and bladder stone surgery versus bladder stone treatment alone: results from a systematic review and meta-analysis of comparative studies by the EAU endourology section. World J Urol. 2026;44(1):520. PubMed
- Manfredi C, García-Gómez B, Arcaniolo D, et al. Impact of surgery for benign prostatic hyperplasia on sexual function: a systematic review and meta-analysis of erectile function and ejaculatory function. Eur Urol Focus. 2022;8(6):1711-1732. PubMed
- Elmansy HM, Kotb A, Elhilali MM. Holmium laser enucleation of the prostate: long-term durability of clinical outcomes and complication rates during 10 years of followup. J Urol. 2011;186(5):1972-6. PubMed
- Shumaker L, Leopold Z, Perilstein M, et al. Robot-assisted transvesical simple prostatectomy with circumferential mucosal anastomosis: long-term urinary and sexual function outcomes in a 292 patient cohort. J Robot Surg. 2025;19(1):693. PubMed
Would you like to talk about your case?
In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.
Book a consultation5.0186 Google reviews
