Skip to content

Simple prostatectomy: open or robotic

What changes between open and robotic surgery, according to the studies that compared them.

Dr. Petronio Melo, urologistA reference in enlarged prostate (BPH) treatment
CRM-SP 157.598 · RQE 70.275
Reviewed by Dr. Petronio Melo on November 15, 2026
Book a consultation
Front-view drawing of the abdomen: on the left, the line of the open surgery incision, below the navel; on the right, the small cuts through which the robot's instruments go in
On this page

Quick answer

Simple prostatectomy removes the benign tissue from inside the prostate and leaves the capsule in place. In open surgery, access is through an incision below the navel, and the tissue comes out through the bladder (transvesical prostatectomy, Freyer's) or through the capsule (retropubic, Millin's).1 In robotic surgery, the logic is the same, through small cuts. In the studies that compared the two, robotic surgery had less bleeding, fewer transfusions, a shorter hospital stay and fewer complications, with a longer operation and similar urinary results.2,3 In my practice, I perform the robotic operation with the modified Millin technique, and the hospital stay is under 24 hours.

What a transvesical prostatectomy is

The name describes the route: "vesical" refers to the bladder. In a transvesical prostatectomy, the surgeon opens the bladder and, from inside it, reaches the prostate tissue that squeezes the urethra. This tissue is separated from the capsule with a finger and removed.1 Peter Freyer published the first cases operated on this way in London, in 1901, which is why it is also called Freyer's operation.4 You may also hear it called suprapubic prostatectomy or transvesical adenomectomy.

In 1945, Terence Millin described another route that does not open the bladder: the surgeon goes through the space between the pubic bone and the bladder, the Retzius space, and opens the prostate capsule from the front.1,5 This is retropubic prostatectomy.

Both routes are still in use. In Germany, from 2013 to 2023, 73% of open simple prostatectomies were done through the bladder, and those done through the capsule had a shorter hospital stay and fewer ICU admissions.6

The steps of the operation through the bladder, how it differs from the route through the capsule, and the alternatives are in transvesical prostatectomy.

Open and robotic: what changes in the operation

In open surgery, the incision is made in the lower abdomen, between the navel and the pubic bone. The surgeon separates the tissue with a finger, through the bladder or through the capsule.1

In robotic surgery, the robot's instruments go in through small cuts in the abdomen. The route can be the same as in open surgery, through the bladder or through the capsule, inside or outside the peritoneum.1 The tissue is separated with the instruments, and the robot gives a magnified view and wristed instruments, which help with suturing in a small space.

Schematic side-view animation of the modified Millin technique, done with the robot. The instruments are simplified.

With the robot, the route chosen seems to matter little. In a study of 45 men operated on with the robot in Rome, through the bladder, through the capsule or with a third technique, symptoms, continence, complications and hospital stay were similar.7

What the studies show

ItemOpenRobotic
Bleeding and transfusionMoreLess
Hospital stayLongerAbout 2.5 days shorter
CatheterLongerAbout 2 days shorter
Operating timeShorterAbout 40 minutes longer
ComplicationsMoreFewer
Symptoms and urinary streamSimilarSimilar

Most of the table comes from a review of 10 studies with 995 men, which pooled robotic and laparoscopic surgery, the small-cut approach without the robot. Compared with open surgery, it had about 290 mL less blood loss, fewer transfusions and fewer complications, with no difference in symptoms, stream, quality of life or the urine left in the bladder.3 A larger review, of 15 studies and 6,659 men, compared robotic surgery with open surgery, laparoscopy and laser. Against open surgery, robotic surgery had fewer complications, a shorter hospital stay, less bleeding and fewer transfusions, and a longer operation, with the same urinary results.2

Pain was measured in few studies. In a study of 73 men, those operated on by laparoscopy used less pain medication than those who had open surgery.8

What large databases show

In the German national inpatient database, with 46,234 simple prostatectomies done from 2013 to 2023 in men without bladder stones, transfusion was 7.3% with the robot and 13% with open surgery through the capsule. Urinary retention in the hospital was 6.4% and 9.3%, and the median hospital stay was 7 and 9 days. Over the period, use of the robot grew, and use of open surgery fell.6

In the United States, in a national sample of 3,255 operations done from 2013 to 2016, complications occurred in 11.1% with the robot and 29.2% with open surgery, and the median hospital stay was 2 and 4 days. The men operated on with the robot were younger and had fewer other illnesses, which weighs on this comparison.9

In a study that matched 59 men in each group by age, weight, other illnesses and prostate size, the hospital stay was 1.5 days with the robot and 2.6 with open surgery, and blood loss was 339 and 587 mL. The operation lasted 161 and 93 minutes. Symptoms, stream and complications were similar.10

Open surgery is still an option

The European guideline considers open surgery the most invasive approach, and also effective and durable. It recommends it, strongly, for prostates above 80 g when endoscopic enucleation is not available.1 In a national study from Austria with 2,452 men, a second operation through the urethra after open surgery occurred in 3% at 1 year and 8.8% at 8 years. The estimated transfusion rate is around 7% to 14%, and late complications, such as persistent urine leakage and narrowing of the bladder neck or urethra, occur in about 6%.1

The robotic or laparoscopic approach is feasible above 80 g, and the guideline still calls for randomized studies comparing it with open surgery and with enucleation.1 In practice, size has to be assessed case by case. For large prostates, HoLEP, done through the urethra, is also part of the conversation.

Ejaculation and erection

Retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common after operations for an enlarged prostate, and erections, after most of them, do not seem to change.11 In my practice, retrograde ejaculation happens in almost every patient after robotic simple prostatectomy. What changes with each technique is in ejaculation and erections.

How I approach it

I have performed robotic simple prostatectomy since 2020, and I have performed more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. I usually use the modified Millin technique: I reach the prostate through the Retzius space, open the capsule, remove the tissue, suture the bladder neck to the urethra and close the capsule. The approach through the bladder, the transvesical one, can also be done with the robot. I use it when there is also a bladder stone, to treat the stone and the prostate at the same time.

In my practice, anesthesia is general, the hospital stay is under 24 hours and the catheter stays for 5 to 7 days. Return to work and to driving is at 2 weeks, and sex and heavy activity after 1 month. If there is a bladder stone, I treat it during the same operation.

For simple prostatectomy, the anticoagulant is always stopped. If you cannot stop it, I consider another type of surgery: in my practice, HoLEP is possible even in people who take anticoagulants, and Greenlight is done without stopping the medication.

Open surgery is still an option, and all techniques are part of the conversation. Before recommending surgery, I look at the size of the prostate, your other illnesses, your medications and what you want to preserve, and we make the decision together.

When to see a urologist

  • If you were advised to have a transvesical or open prostatectomy and want to compare it with robotic surgery
  • If your prostate is large and medications do not bring enough relief
  • If you have had urinary retention or use a catheter
  • If you take an anticoagulant and need prostate surgery

Send your case

If you would like to know, before a consultation, which technique makes sense for your case, fill in the form below. If you know it, tell me the prostate weight on ultrasound or MRI and the medications you take. It goes to my office, and you will get a reply within 24 hours by email or WhatsApp. The form does not replace a consultation: it helps plan the next step.

Frequently asked questions

What is a transvesical prostatectomy?

It is a simple prostatectomy in which the surgeon opens the bladder and, from inside it, removes the benign prostate tissue that squeezes the urethra. This is the route described by Freyer. The other route, Millin's, reaches the tissue through the prostate capsule, without opening the bladder.1,4

What is the difference between open and robotic simple prostatectomy?

In open surgery, access is through an incision in the lower abdomen, below the navel. In robotic surgery, the instruments go in through small cuts. The tissue removed is the same, and in both the route to it can be through the bladder or through the capsule.1

Does robotic surgery bleed less than open surgery?

In the studies, yes. In a German national database with 46,234 simple prostatectomies, transfusion was 7.3% with the robot and 13% with open surgery through the capsule.6 In a review of 10 studies, blood loss was about 290 mL lower with surgery through small cuts.3

How long are the hospital stay and the catheter with each one?

In a review of 10 studies with 995 men, surgery through small cuts had a hospital stay about 2.5 days shorter and a catheter time about 2 days shorter than open surgery.3 In my practice, robotic surgery has a hospital stay under 24 hours, and the catheter stays for 5 to 7 days.

Is the urinary result different?

In the studies, no. Symptoms, stream, quality of life and the urine left in the bladder were similar with both.2,3

Can a transvesical prostatectomy be done with the robot?

Yes. Robotic surgery follows the route through the bladder (Freyer) or through the capsule (Millin).1 In a study of 45 men operated on with the robot, symptoms, continence, complications and hospital stay did not differ between the routes.7 I usually use the modified Millin technique, through the Retzius space.

Is open surgery still done?

Yes. The European guideline considers it effective and durable and recommends it for prostates above 80 g when endoscopic enucleation is not available.1 In Germany, 96% of simple prostatectomies from 2013 to 2023 were open.6

Who performs robotic simple prostatectomy in São Paulo?

I am Dr. Petronio Melo, a urologist and robotic surgeon, CRM-SP 157.598 and RQE 70.275. I have performed robotic simple prostatectomy since 2020, using the modified Millin technique, and I have performed more than 1,500 robotic and laparoscopic operations, more than 500 of them robotic. In my practice, the hospital stay is under 24 hours, and the catheter stays for 5 to 7 days. My office is in Vila Mariana, and the first consultation can be in person or online, in English.

References

  1. EAU Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male LUTS. European Association of Urology; 2026. Disease management chapter. EAU
  2. Pandolfo SD, Del Giudice F, Chung BI, et al. Robotic assisted simple prostatectomy versus other treatment modalities for large benign prostatic hyperplasia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of over 6500 cases. Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis. 2023;26(3):495-510. PubMed
  3. Li J, Cao D, Peng L, et al. Comparison Between Minimally Invasive Simple Prostatectomy and Open Simple Prostatectomy for Large Prostates: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Comparative Trials. J Endourol. 2019;33(9):767-776. PubMed
  4. Freyer PJ. A clinical lecture on total extirpation of the prostate for radical cure of enlargement of that organ: with four successful cases. Br Med J. 1901;2(2116):125-9. PubMed
  5. Millin T. Retropubic prostatectomy: a new extravesical technique report on 20 cases. 1945. J Urol. 2002;167(2 Pt 2):976-9. PubMed
  6. Pyrgidis N, Weinhold P, Schulz GB, et al. Peri-operative outcomes of open, laparoscopic and robotic simple prostatectomy. BJU Int. 2025;136(6):1107-1113. PubMed
  7. Bove AM, Anceschi U, Ferriero M, et al. Perioperative and 1-year patient-reported outcomes of Freyer versus Millin versus Madigan robot-assisted simple prostatectomy. World J Urol. 2021;39(6):2005-2010. PubMed
  8. Demir A, Günseren KÖ, Kordan Y, et al. Open vs Laparoscopic Simple Prostatectomy: A Comparison of Initial Outcomes and Cost. J Endourol. 2016;30(8):884-9. PubMed
  9. Bhanvadia R, Ashbrook C, Gahan J, et al. Perioperative outcomes and cost of robotic vs open simple prostatectomy in the modern robotic era: results from the National Inpatient Sample. BJU Int. 2021;128(2):168-177. PubMed
  10. Sorokin I, Sundaram V, Singla N, et al. Robot-Assisted Versus Open Simple Prostatectomy for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia in Large Glands: A Propensity Score-Matched Comparison of Perioperative and Short-Term Outcomes. J Endourol. 2017;31(11):1164-1169. PubMed
  11. Manfredi C, García-Gómez B, Arcaniolo D, et al. Impact of Surgery for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia on Sexual Function: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Erectile Function and Ejaculatory Function. Eur Urol Focus. 2022;8(6):1711-1732. PubMed

Would you like to talk about your case?

In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.

Book a consultation5.0186 Google reviews

Related guides