Quick answer
For kidney stones larger than 2 cm, the European guideline makes percutaneous surgery the first choice, and ureteroscopy is used when percutaneous surgery is not an option.1 Across 42 studies, percutaneous surgery left more patients stone-free and needed fewer further procedures, with similar major complications and a hospital stay about 1 day longer.2 In my practice, as a general rule, I recommend percutaneous surgery above 2 cm, and each case is assessed individually.
How each one works
In ureteroscopy, a thin scope goes in through the urethra, moves up the ureter and reaches the stone, which is broken up with a laser. There is no cut in the skin.1
In percutaneous surgery, a small access through the side or the back goes straight to the kidney. Through this tunnel, the stone is broken up and the fragments are removed.1

What the studies show
A Cochrane review pooled 42 studies with 4,571 patients, with stones of 10 to 39 mm on average.2
| Item | Ureteroscopy | Percutaneous surgery |
|---|---|---|
| Stone-free | 77 in 100 | About 87 in 100 |
| Further procedure | 22 in 100 | About 7 in 100 |
| Major complications | Similar | Similar |
| Hospital stay | Shorter | About 1 day longer |
| Access | Through the urethra, no cut | Small cut in the side or back |
The first four rows come from the Cochrane review. The certainty of the evidence is low for almost all outcomes, and most studies used percutaneous accesses smaller than the standard size.2
How stone size and location change the choice
The European guideline recommends:1
- Above 2 cm, percutaneous surgery is the first choice. Ureteroscopy is used when percutaneous surgery is not an option, with a higher risk of a further procedure and a double J stent
- In the lower part of the kidney, both are options, even above 1 cm
- Stones up to 3 cm can be treated with ureteroscopy, depending on the surgeon's experience, but often in more than one stage
In the lower part of the kidney, a narrow angle at the exit of the calyx makes ureteroscopy harder.1 A British trial randomly assigned 159 adults with stones of 10 to 25 mm in that area: the kidney was stone-free in 71% after percutaneous surgery and in 48% after ureteroscopy, and quality of life over the following 12 weeks was slightly better with percutaneous surgery.3
For complex stones, percutaneous surgery and flexible ureteroscopy can be done together, in the same operation. The European guideline mentions this combination as a good alternative, with evidence that is still limited.1
How I approach it
In my practice, as a general rule, I recommend percutaneous surgery for kidney stones larger than 2 cm. Each case is assessed individually, and sometimes it is also the right choice for smaller stones.
After ureteroscopy, the hospital stay is under 12 hours. After percutaneous surgery, the stay is 24 hours; the patient always lies face up, and whenever possible I operate without a nephrostomy tube. With both, a double J stent is usually left in place. Before deciding, I study the CT scan and talk with the patient about the chance of needing more than one procedure.
When to see a urologist
- If a scan shows a large kidney stone, even without pain
- If the pain comes back even with medication
- If you have fever or chills along with the pain
- If a scan shows that the stone has grown or that the kidney is dilated
- If you have already had surgery and a stone was left in the kidney
Frequently asked questions
Kidney stone larger than 2 cm: ureteroscopy or percutaneous surgery?+
Above 2 cm, the European guideline makes percutaneous surgery the first choice. Ureteroscopy is used when percutaneous surgery is not an option, with a higher risk of needing a further procedure and a double J stent.1 In my practice, as a general rule, I recommend percutaneous surgery above 2 cm, and each case is assessed individually.
Which one is more likely to leave the kidney stone-free?+
Percutaneous surgery. In a Cochrane review of 42 studies, it left about 100 more patients per 1,000 stone-free and reduced the need for further procedures. The certainty of this evidence is low.2
Which one has more complications?+
In the same review, major complications were similar with both. The hospital stay was, on average, about 1 day longer after percutaneous surgery.2
What if the stone is in the lower part of the kidney?+
The European guideline accepts both, even above 1 cm.1 In a British trial of stones of 10 to 25 mm in that area, the kidney was stone-free in 71% after percutaneous surgery and in 48% after ureteroscopy.3
Can both be done in the same operation?+
Yes. For complex stones, the European guideline mentions combining percutaneous surgery with flexible ureteroscopy as a good alternative, with evidence that is still limited.1
References
- EAU Guidelines on Urolithiasis. European Association of Urology; 2026. Guidelines chapter. EAU
- Soderberg L, Ergun O, Ding M, et al. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy versus retrograde intrarenal surgery for treatment of renal stones in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2023;11(11):CD013445. PubMed
- Smith D, Wiseman O, Starr K, et al. PUrE Randomised Controlled Trial 2: Clinical and Cost Effectiveness of Flexible Ureterorenoscopy and Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy for Lower-pole Stones of 10-25 mm. Eur Urol Focus. 2025;11(5):684-694. PubMed
Would you like to talk about your case?
In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.
Book a consultation
