Skip to content

Second opinion before enlarged prostate surgery

When to ask, what to bring, the questions to ask and the techniques I compare with you before surgery.

Dr. Petronio Melo, urologistA reference in enlarged prostate (BPH) treatment
CRM-SP 157.598 · RQE 70.275
Reviewed by Dr. Petronio Melo on November 19, 2026
Book a consultation
Drawing of the same enlarged prostate seen in two ways. On the left, from the front, below the bladder, with the central tissue squeezing the urethra. On the right, a hand magnifying glass shows the gland in cross-section, seen from above, with the enlarged central part and the urethra squeezed into a slit, and a dashed line links the two views
On this page

Quick answer

If you have been told you need surgery for an enlarged prostate, often TURP, and want to know whether there is another option, a second opinion helps. The European guideline recommends each technique for different situations, depending on prostate size, symptoms and the patient's other health conditions.1 The techniques also differ in ejaculation, blood thinners, catheter time and insurance. Bring the ultrasound with the prostate weight in grams, your PSA, the IPSS, the uroflowmetry, the residual urine and the list of your medications. In my practice, a second opinion before enlarged prostate surgery can always be fully online, in English.

When a second opinion helps

Surgery for an enlarged prostate is indicated when complications appear, such as urinary retention that comes back, repeated infections, bladder stones, bleeding that does not stop or swelling of the kidneys. It is also an option when lifestyle changes and medications do not help enough.1 Details are in when to have surgery for an enlarged prostate and when medication stops working.

Asking for another opinion is part of deciding well, and it does not mean you distrust the urologist who recommended surgery. It tends to help in these situations:

  • You have heard about a single technique and want to know whether others suit your case
  • You want to preserve ejaculation
  • You take a blood thinner or antiplatelet drug and do not know whether you can stop it
  • The prostate is very large or has a lobe pushing into the bladder, the median lobe
  • You already have a catheter because of urinary retention, or feel your bladder does not empty
  • You want to understand catheter time, recovery and what your plan covers before setting a date

What to bring

The European guideline assesses an enlarged prostate through symptoms, the urine test, the urinary stream, the urine left in the bladder and, when surgery is being considered, the size of the prostate.2 These are the most useful documents:

Test or documentWhy it helps
Prostate ultrasoundGives the weight in grams and sometimes shows a median lobe, which weighs on the choice of technique2
PSA, with datesUsed when the result changes management2
IPSSMeasures how much the symptoms bother you2; you can take the IPSS questionnaire on this site
UroflowmetryMeasures the strength of the stream2
Post-void residualMeasures the urine left in the bladder after urinating2
Urine testLooks for infection and other changes2
List of medicationsIncludes prostate medications and the name of any blood thinner or antiplatelet drug
Report with the recommendationShows what was proposed and why

If you take finasteride or dutasteride, let me know. These drugs lower PSA, and in my practice I double the value to interpret the test. If you get up many times at night to urinate, I ask for a 3-day bladder diary, as I explain in nocturia. If you have had a urodynamic study, bring it too: it is not for everyone and is used in specific situations before an invasive treatment.2

Questions to ask

These questions help compare the options, with me or with any urologist:

  • What does my prostate weigh, in grams, and does it have a median lobe?
  • Which techniques suit my case, and why was this one chosen?
  • What will happen to my ejaculation?
  • Do I need to stop my blood thinner? For how long?
  • Will I stay in hospital? How long will I have a catheter?
  • When can I go back to work, driving, sex and the gym?
  • Does my plan cover this technique? What will I pay myself?

Recovery for each technique, side by side, is in recovery after each enlarged prostate operation, and changes in sexual function in ejaculation and erections.

The techniques I compare with you

Some techniques remove the tissue squeezing the urethra, some vaporize it and some treat it from the inside without removing anything.1 I perform all of these and compare with you the ones that suit your case:

TechniqueBlood thinnersCatheter
TURPStopped whenever possibleOut before discharge, with a 1 to 2 day stay
GreenlightI operate without stopping themOut before discharge, with a stay under 24 hours
HoLEPStopped when possible; if not, I operate with the medicationOut before discharge, usually with a stay under 24 hours
RezumCase by case5 to 7 days, removed at my office
EchoLaserCase by case7 days, removed at my office
Robotic simpleAlways stopped; when that is not possible, I consider another operation5 to 7 days

The data in the table come from my practice, and the decision about blood thinners is always made together with the doctor who prescribed them. I also assess ThuLEP and less invasive options such as Urolift, iTind and Aquablation with each patient; they are covered in other techniques.

TURP. The European guideline treats TURP as the standard operation for prostates of 30 to 80 g, and the 80 g limit came from expert consensus.1 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case. I have performed TURP since 2015, in both monopolar and bipolar forms. Greenlight and TURP are both good operations; I have been giving priority to Greenlight because of its safety profile and lower risk of bleeding. If you were told you need TURP, the side-by-side comparisons are in Greenlight or TURP, HoLEP or TURP, Rezum or TURP and EchoLaser or TURP.

Ejaculation. After TURP, Greenlight and HoLEP, retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common.1,3 In my practice, HoLEP almost never preserves ejaculation. Rezum tends to preserve it in 80% to 90% of cases.4,5

Blood thinners. For men who need to keep taking a blood thinner or antiplatelet drug, the European guideline recommends offering laser vaporization, such as Greenlight, for prostates under 80 g, as a weak recommendation.1 In a 2026 review of 15 studies and 6,091 men, those who kept the medication had more bleeding complications after TURP and enucleation; after Greenlight, transfusion and repeat surgery for bleeding were at rates similar to those of men not taking these drugs.6 More in prostate surgery on blood thinners or with a catheter.

Prostate size. It matters, but it does not decide on its own. The shape of the gland, a median lobe, a catheter you already use and the wish to preserve ejaculation also count. The comparison is in which technique for each prostate size.

Insurance and cost

TURP and laser photovaporization, which is Greenlight, are on the list of procedures Brazilian health plans must cover (the ANS list). HoLEP and Rezum are not, and EchoLaser does not appear on it.7 In my practice, plans cover the hospital stay and materials for Greenlight and authorize the stay and materials for TURP. For EchoLaser, plans have covered the stay and the material. For HoLEP, plans do not cover the special materials. Rezum is fully private, including the hospital, the material and the team. For robotic simple prostatectomy, coverage varies widely from plan to plan.

My practice is private: the team's fees are paid separately, with an invoice for reimbursement, as I explain in insurance and reimbursement. I do not publish prices. The estimate comes within 24 hours after the consultation and is valid for 30 days, and what it includes is in surgery quote. The cost of each technique is in how much prostate surgery costs. If you live outside Brazil, travel, costs and payment are in international patients.

Online second opinion

In my practice, a second opinion before enlarged prostate surgery can always be fully online. You send me your tests beforehand, and we go through each of them by video, as in an in-person consultation, in English. This helps if you live far from São Paulo or want to hear another urologist without traveling. The online consultation page explains how to book.

How I approach it

I have performed Greenlight since 2019, with more than 500 procedures, which places me among the urologists with the most Greenlight procedures in Brazil. I was one of the Rezum pioneers in Brazil, with some of the first procedures in the country in July 2023, and I have more than 100 cases between my own patients and proctoring. I am a proctor for both techniques and teach other urologists in their first cases, as I explain in Rezum and Greenlight proctoring. I have performed HoLEP since 2022, using the en bloc technique, TURP since 2015 and EchoLaser since 2025, when the technique arrived in Brazil.

In a second opinion, I look at the diagnosis before the technique. I read the reports, check the weight and shape of the prostate and ask what you want to preserve. Then we compare the options that suit your case, with what weighs for and against each one, including the technique already recommended to you. Before major surgery, I always ask for a cardiology assessment. An overview of all the operations is in prostate surgery in São Paulo.

Send your case

If you have been told you need surgery and would like to know, before a consultation, which options make sense for your case, fill in the form below. It goes to my office, and you will get a reply within 24 hours by email or WhatsApp. The form does not replace a consultation: it helps plan the next step.

Frequently asked questions

Is a second opinion worth it before enlarged prostate surgery?

Often, yes. There are several techniques for an enlarged prostate, and the European guideline recommends each one for different situations, depending on prostate size, symptoms and the patient's other health conditions.1 They also differ in ejaculation, blood thinners, catheter time and insurance coverage. A second opinion helps you know the options before you decide.

Can the second opinion be fully online?

Always. You send me your tests beforehand, and we go through each of them by video, just as in an in-person consultation, in English.

What should I bring to the second opinion?

The ultrasound report with the prostate weight in grams, your PSA results with dates, the IPSS, the uroflowmetry, the post-void residual, the urine test and the list of medications you take, with the name of any blood thinner or antiplatelet drug. The European guideline uses these tests to assess the symptoms and, when surgery is being considered, to measure the prostate.2 Also bring the report with the recommendation you received.

Is TURP a good operation?

Yes. The European guideline treats TURP as the standard operation for prostates of 30 to 80 g, and the 80 g limit came from expert consensus.1 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case. I have performed TURP since 2015, in both monopolar and bipolar forms.

Is there prostate surgery that preserves ejaculation?

After TURP, Greenlight and HoLEP, retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is very common.1,3 Rezum tends to preserve ejaculation in 80% to 90% of cases.4,5 That is why I ask what you want to preserve before talking about technique.

I take blood thinners. Do I need to stop them for prostate surgery?

It depends on the technique. In my practice, I perform Greenlight without stopping the blood thinner, and HoLEP is also possible for men who cannot stop it. In a 2026 review, transfusion and repeat surgery for bleeding after Greenlight were at rates similar to those of men not taking these drugs.6 The decision is made together with the doctor who prescribed the medication, and you should never stop it on your own.

Do Brazilian health plans cover enlarged prostate surgery?

It depends on the technique. TURP and laser photovaporization, which is Greenlight, are on the list of procedures Brazilian health plans must cover, set by the national agency (ANS); HoLEP and Rezum are not, and EchoLaser does not appear on the list.7 My practice is private. When a plan covers the procedure, it may pay the hospital stay and materials, and the team's fees are paid separately, with an invoice for reimbursement.

Who gives a second opinion before prostate surgery in São Paulo?

I give second opinions before enlarged prostate surgery in São Paulo, and they can be fully online, in English. I am Dr. Petronio Melo, a urologist and robotic surgeon, CRM-SP 157.598 and RQE 70.275, with a PhD from the University of São Paulo School of Medicine. I have performed Greenlight since 2019, with more than 500 procedures, and I am among the urologists with the most Greenlight procedures in Brazil. I was one of the Rezum pioneers in Brazil, with some of the first procedures in the country in July 2023, and I am a proctor for both techniques. I also perform HoLEP, EchoLaser, TURP and robotic simple prostatectomy. My office is in Vila Mariana, and the first consultation can be in person or online.

References

  1. EAU Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male LUTS. European Association of Urology; 2026. Disease management chapter. EAU
  2. EAU Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male LUTS. European Association of Urology; 2026. Diagnostic evaluation chapter. EAU
  3. Manfredi C, García-Gómez B, Arcaniolo D, et al. Impact of Surgery for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia on Sexual Function: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Erectile Function and Ejaculatory Function. Eur Urol Focus. 2022;8(6):1711-1732. PubMed
  4. Destefanis P, Sibona M, Oderda M, et al. Ejaculation-sparing GreenLight anatomical PVP versus REZŪM for benign prostatic obstruction surgery with an ejaculation-sparing purpose: what are the early differences? Minim Invasive Ther Allied Technol. 2026;35(5):383-391. PubMed
  5. Long Depaquit T, Berchiche W, Uleri A, et al. Two-Year Outcomes of Rezūm Therapy in Real-Life BPH Patients. Prostate. 2026;86(3):314-319. PubMed
  6. Giulioni C, Cafarelli A, Falsetti F, et al. Perioperative outcomes of ongoing antithrombotic therapy during endoscopic surgery for benign prostatic hyperplasia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies. Prostate Cancer Prostatic Dis. 2026;29(4):735-753. PubMed
  7. Agência Nacional de Saúde Suplementar (ANS). Rol de Procedimentos e Eventos em Saúde. Annex I of Normative Resolution 465/2021 and amendments (version updated by RN 682/2026). ANS

Would you like to talk about your case?

In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.

Book a consultation5.0186 Google reviews

Related guides