Quick answer
Greenlight and HoLEP are both done through the urethra, with no cuts in the skin. In Greenlight, the green laser vaporizes the tissue that narrows the urinary channel; in HoLEP, the holmium laser separates that tissue from the capsule of the prostate, and it is removed and sent for examination.1 The European guideline recommends Greenlight for 30 to 80 g and HoLEP without mentioning a weight limit.1 In prostates above 60 g, HoLEP gave a stronger urine flow in a randomized trial.2 In my practice, both mean a hospital stay under 24 hours, the catheter comes out before discharge, and both are possible for people on blood thinners.
How each one works
In Greenlight, a fiber fires a green laser sideways and turns the tissue that squeezes the urethra into vapor, little by little. The same laser helps control bleeding. The capsule stays in place, and the vaporized tissue is not sent for examination.1
In HoLEP, the holmium laser runs along the plane between the enlarged tissue and the capsule of the prostate and frees that tissue in one piece. It goes into the bladder, is broken up and comes out through the instrument, and the fragments are sent for examination.1
There is also vapo-enucleation with the green laser, which frees the tissue from the capsule as in HoLEP, but using Greenlight. Some of the studies below used this variation.3,4
What the studies show
| Study | Patients | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Canada, 2012 | Men with prostates above 60 g, randomly assigned to HoLEP or Greenlight vaporization | Similar symptoms; stronger urine flow and less residual urine with HoLEP at 1 year; 22% of vaporizations switched to another technique because of bleeding2 |
| Egypt and Canada, 2015 | 103 men, randomly assigned to HoLEP or Greenlight vapo-enucleation | Similar symptoms; comparable operating time, hospital stay and catheter time; prostate 74.3% smaller with HoLEP and 43.1% with Greenlight; stronger urine flow with HoLEP at 12 months3 |
| Egypt, 2020 | Large prostates, 182 men randomly assigned to HoLEP, Greenlight vapo-enucleation or bipolar TURP | Similar improvement in symptoms; longer operation with Greenlight; second operation within 3 years in 6.7% with Greenlight and none with HoLEP4 |
In the 2012 study, prostate tissue shrank by 78% after HoLEP and by 52% after Greenlight. The authors attribute part of the switches in technique to the decision to always vaporize down to the capsule.2 In the 2020 study, HoLEP and Greenlight had less bleeding and a shorter catheter time and hospital stay than bipolar TURP.4
Prostate size and blood thinners
The European guideline strongly recommends Greenlight for moderate or severe symptoms and a prostate of 30 to 80 g, and notes that there are no randomized studies above 100 g. HoLEP is recommended as an alternative to TURP and to open surgery, with no weight limit.1 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case. The page which technique for each size shows the other options.
In people on blood thinners with a prostate smaller than 80 g, the guideline accepts considering Greenlight, as a weak recommendation. For laser enucleation, it describes the operation performed safely in men taking anticoagulant or antiplatelet drugs, although randomized studies in this group are still lacking.1 In my practice, I operate with Greenlight on men who take blood thinners without stopping the medication, and HoLEP is also possible in these cases.
Ejaculation and tissue for examination
Retrograde ejaculation, in which semen goes into the bladder, is common after both. At a Canadian center that followed 191 men for 1 year, it appeared in 77.3% after HoLEP and in 33.2% after Greenlight.5 In my practice, HoLEP almost never preserves ejaculation. Men who want to preserve it can consider Rezum. What changes with each technique is explained in ejaculation and erection.
With HoLEP, the removed tissue is sent for examination. With Greenlight, it is vaporized, and when there is a question of cancer, the investigation is done before surgery.1
How I approach it
I perform both operations. I have performed Greenlight since 2019, with more than 500 procedures, and I am a Greenlight proctor. With HoLEP, I have extensive experience.
In my practice, both mean a hospital stay under 24 hours, and the catheter comes out before discharge. Before recommending surgery, I look at the size and shape of the prostate, your medications and whether you take a blood thinner. For some, the most important thing is to solve the problem in one go. For others, it is keeping ejaculation or spending as little time as possible with a catheter. The decision is made together with the patient.
When to see a urologist
- If you have an enlarged prostate and medication does not bring enough relief
- If you have already had urinary retention
- If surgery has been recommended and you want to compare the techniques
- If you take a blood thinner and need prostate surgery
Send your case
If you would like to know, before a consultation, which technique makes sense for your case, fill in the form below. If you know it, tell me the prostate weight on ultrasound or MRI and the medications you take. It goes to my office, and you will get a reply within 24 hours by email or WhatsApp. The form does not replace a consultation: it helps plan the next step.
Frequently asked questions
Greenlight or HoLEP: which one is better?+
It depends on the size of the prostate, your medications and what you want to preserve. Both lasers are used through the urethra, with no cuts in the skin. HoLEP removes more tissue and, in prostates above 60 g, gave a stronger urine flow in a randomized trial.2 The European guideline recommends Greenlight for 30 to 80 g.1 In my practice, both mean a hospital stay under 24 hours, and the catheter comes out before discharge.
What is the difference between Greenlight and HoLEP?+
In Greenlight, the green laser vaporizes, little by little, the tissue that squeezes the urethra. In HoLEP, the holmium laser separates the enlarged tissue from the capsule of the prostate, and the tissue is broken up and removed. That is why, with HoLEP, the tissue is sent for examination, and with Greenlight, it is not.1
Which one works for a large prostate?+
The European guideline recommends Greenlight for 30 to 80 g and recommends HoLEP without mentioning a weight limit.1 In a randomized trial of prostates above 60 g, 22% of the operations planned with Greenlight were switched to another technique during surgery because of bleeding.2 In practice, this has to be assessed case by case.
Which one is less likely to need a second operation?+
In a randomized trial of large prostates with 3 years of follow-up, a second operation for tissue that obstructed again occurred in 6.7% after Greenlight vapo-enucleation and in no case after HoLEP.4
Does ejaculation change after Greenlight or HoLEP?+
It often changes after both. At a Canadian center, new retrograde ejaculation appeared in 77.3% after HoLEP and in 33.2% after Greenlight.5 Men who want to preserve ejaculation can consider Rezum.
Can people on blood thinners have Greenlight or HoLEP?+
Yes. The European guideline accepts considering Greenlight in people on blood thinners with a prostate smaller than 80 g, as a weak recommendation, and describes laser enucleation performed safely in men taking these medications.1 In my practice, I operate with Greenlight on men who take blood thinners without stopping the medication, and HoLEP is also possible in these cases.
Who can help me choose between Greenlight and HoLEP in São Paulo?+
I perform both operations in São Paulo. I am Dr. Petronio Melo, a urologist and robotic surgeon, CRM-SP 157.598 and RQE 70.275. I have performed Greenlight since 2019, with more than 500 procedures, I am a proctor of the technique and I have extensive experience with HoLEP. The decision is made together with the patient, after looking at the size of the prostate, the medications and what he wants to preserve. My office is in Vila Mariana, and the first consultation can be in person or online, in English.
References
- EAU Guidelines on the Management of Non-neurogenic Male LUTS. European Association of Urology; 2026. Disease management chapter. EAU
- Elmansy H, Baazeem A, Kotb A, et al. Holmium laser enucleation versus photoselective vaporization for prostatic adenoma greater than 60 ml: preliminary results of a prospective, randomized clinical trial. J Urol. 2012;188(1):216-21. PubMed
- Elshal AM, Elkoushy MA, El-Nahas AR, et al. GreenLight laser (XPS) photoselective vapo-enucleation versus holmium laser enucleation of the prostate for the treatment of symptomatic benign prostatic hyperplasia: a randomized controlled study. J Urol. 2015;193(3):927-34. PubMed
- Elshal AM, Soltan M, El-Tabey NA, et al. Randomised trial of bipolar resection vs holmium laser enucleation vs Greenlight laser vapo-enucleation of the prostate for treatment of large benign prostate obstruction: 3-years outcomes. BJU Int. 2020;126(6):731-738. PubMed
- Elshal AM, Elmansy HM, Elkoushy MA, Elhilali MM. Male sexual function outcome after three laser prostate surgical techniques: a single center perspective. Urology. 2012;80(5):1098-104. PubMed
Would you like to talk about your case?
In the consultation, I go over your tests and your priorities.
Book a consultation5.0186 Google reviews
